big city

Unveiling the Secrets of NY S Corps: A Comprehensive Overview

Choosing the right business structure to minimize tax liability can be daunting. An S corporation can save your money in New York through tax savings.

By the end of this guide, you will understand how these entities work and the benefits they provide. You will learn about the formation requirements, compliance obligations, and operational considerations for S corporations. With this thorough understanding, you can work with an S-corp formation attorney to decide how to incorporate your business.

What Is an S Corporation?

new york s corporation

An S corporation is a legal business entity. It limits owners' liability for corporate debts and legal liabilities. It also allows pass-through taxation, thus avoiding the double taxation of C corporations.

To form an S corporation, you must file articles of incorporation to form a corporation, or articles of organization to form a limited liability company, with New York State and inform state and federal tax agencies that you elect treatment as an S corp. The corporation is owned by shareholders or members, and it must follow prescribed formalities to maintain its status.

Advantages of an S Corp for Small Business Owners

The greatest benefit of an S corporation is the tax savings it can provide to New York small businesses. S corps are also limited liability entities. Finally, S corporations have flexibility in how owners distribute profits and transfer ownership shares.

Advantages Description
Pass-Through Taxation S Corps are not subject to double taxation. Business profits and losses pass through to the shareholders' tax returns, avoiding corporate-level taxes. This can result in potential tax savings for small business owners.
Limited Liability Protection As a separate legal entity, an S Corp provides limited liability protection to its shareholders. This means that the personal assets of the owners are generally protected from business debts and liabilities.
Tax Savings on Self-Employment Tax S Corp owners who are actively involved in the business can potentially save on self-employment taxes. They can classify a portion of their income as salary (subject to payroll taxes) and the remaining as distributions (not subject to self-employment taxes).
Credibility and Prestige Operating as an S Corp can enhance the credibility and perception of your business, making it more attractive to potential clients, partners, and lenders. It demonstrates a formal corporate structure and commitment to compliance.
Flexibility in Profit Distribution S Corps offers flexibility in distributing profits among shareholders. This can be beneficial for tax planning purposes, allowing owners to allocate profits in a way that minimizes their overall tax liability.
Easy Transfer of Ownership Ownership in an S Corp can be easily transferred through the sale or transfer of stock. This can provide flexibility when planning for business succession or bringing in new investors.

The advantages of an S corporation come from its taxation, limited liability, and flexible ownership. You should consider an S corp and whether it addresses your company's needs and challenges. Contact a lawyer or financial professional to determine whether this entity provides long-term cost savings and improved business operations.

Disadvantages of an S Corp for Small Business Owners

The biggest disadvantage of S corps is the rule that governs how owners can be compensated. Taxing authorities will not set your salary, but they can tell you when you can and cannot take profit distributions (on which you pay no payroll taxes).

Before owners can take profit distributions, the company must pay them a reasonable minimum salary. This requirement ensures that owners cannot reclassify their compensation to evade payroll taxes.

This disadvantage is most burdensome on start-ups with minimal revenue. However, this requirement does not apply to LLCs, which often makes LLCs a better starting point until your business makes enough profit to pay salaries to shareholders.

Other disadvantages of S corporations include an imposed limit on the number of shareholders and the accounting-intensive process for generating tax schedules for each shareholder.

Requirements and Regulations for Forming an S Corp in New York

This table explains the requirements for forming a New York S corporation. Understanding these requirements will ensure you avail yourself of the cost savings provided. Also, by complying with the regulations, you will make informed decisions and maintain your company's legal and tax status.

Requirement/Regulation Description
Business Entity Type To form an S Corp in New York, you must first establish your business as a limited liability company or domestic corporation by filing the necessary formation documents with the New York Department of State.
Shareholder Eligibility An S Corp in New York can have a maximum of 100 shareholders. Eligible shareholders must be individuals, estates, certain trusts, or tax-exempt organizations. Non-resident aliens are generally not allowed to be shareholders.
Election for S Corp Status Once your corporation or limited liability company is formed, you need to file Form 2553 with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) to elect S Corp status for federal tax purposes. New York State also recognizes the federal S Corp election, eliminating the need for a separate state-level election.
Tax Reporting and Compliance As an S Corp, you must file an annual federal tax return (Form 1120S) and report income, deductions, and other tax-related information. Additionally, you are required to file New York State tax returns and comply with state tax regulations.
Ongoing Corporate Compliance A corporation or limited liability company electing S Corps status in New York must comply with various corporate formalities, such as holding regular shareholder and director meetings, keeping accurate corporate records, and maintaining proper financial statements. Compliance with these requirements is essential to maintain the liability protection provided by the corporate structure.
Licensing and Permits Depending on the nature of your business, you may need to obtain specific licenses, permits, or certifications at the state, county, or local level. It's important to research and comply with all applicable regulatory requirements.

You form S corps for entities with 100 or fewer shareholders by filing with the state. You elect pass-through treatment by the IRS. You will file an annual tax return. Consult a professional to ensure you fully understand and comply with state law.

Step-by-Step Guide to Converting to NY S Corp

You can get the benefits of an S corp by converting your C corp or sole proprietorship. Make sure you understand the requirements under New York corporation laws.

The following steps provide a comprehensive resource to help small business owners navigate a conversion to an S corp smoothly and cost-effectively.

Step 1. Filing Necessary Forms and Documents for New York S Corporation Status

new york filing requirements

If you have a limited liability company (LLC), you have two options for receiving the benefits of an S corp: You can either form a new S corporation and move all of your LLC’s assets into it, or you can simply elect S corp status for your new or existing LLC. The second option eliminates the need to move the LLC’s assets and liabilities to a new S corp.

You can exercise the first option by forming a new S corp and shutting down your existing LLC or sole proprietorship. You start by forming a New York S corp by filing articles of organization for a limited liability company (LLC), or articles of incorporation for a corporation, with the New York Department of State.

Once you have your small business corporation or LLC, you file Form CT-6 with the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance for New York S corp status. You file Form 2553 with the Internal Revenue Service for recognition as a federal S corporation.

You can exercise the second option by filing IRS Form 8832 to elect pass-through tax treatment and New York State Form CT-6 to elect S corp treatment for a new or existing LLC.

Step 2. Notifying Stakeholders and Employees

Owners and employees must be involved in the conversion. You must notify corporation shareholders and directors, or members of limited liability companies. You might even need a shareholder or member to vote to approve it since their personal income tax obligations could change. You need to update all your contracts, including employment agreements, to reflect the new entity.

Finally, you will need to review and implement changes in withholdings and payroll deductions for both S corp owners and employees. As an S corp, you must pay a “reasonable minimum salary” to each owner of the S-corp for services provided, before any distributions may be made to that same individual. You should verify with a seasoned business attorney what qualifies as “reasonable” for your operations.

Step 3. Updating Tax Obligations and Filings

nys s corp tax rates

Based on which action you take, if you form a new New York S corp, you must get new taxpayer identification numbers and accounts for state and federal taxes. You should work with an accountant to review the company's accounting methods and financial reporting and adjust them if necessary to comply with tax regulations.

Finally, you need to make sure your tax preparers file the S corp's tax return correctly to get all the benefits of a pass-through entity.

Step 4. Transferring Assets and Liabilities

If instead of forming a new New York S Corp, you simply change your corp status, your converted entity already owns all the company's assets and liabilities. But if you change the business structure by forming a new S corporation, you need to move all assets to the new entity, including:

  • Accounts receivable
  • Accounts payable
  • Real estate
  • Intellectual property
  • Debts
  • Contractual obligations

Review your company's assets, liabilities, and agreements with your legal and financial team to make sure you understand the effects of this transfer.

Tax Implications and Potential Savings of S Corporations

Most S corps exist for tax purposes. C corps are subject to double taxation. A corporation with New York receipts pays corporate tax on its taxable income. You then pay federal income taxes on the dividends or salary paid by the corporation to you.

In contrast, business profits of S corps are only taxed once. S corps do not pay corporate income tax. Instead, the tax obligations pass through the corporation to its owners. For pass-through entities, S corp shareholders only pay taxes on their share of the company's net income for that tax year.

Another tax benefit is that you can save on self-employment tax by paying yourself a reasonable salary rather than receiving ownership distributions. You should consult a tax professional to fully understand the tax savings.

Compliance Obligations for NY S Corporations

how to start an s corp in ny

An S corp must file documents with both the state and federal government. You must file articles of incorporation for a corporation, or articles of organization for a limited liability company, along with a filing fee, with the New York Department of State and a Form 2553 with the IRS to elect S corp status. New York corporations that file Form 2553 are recognized by the state as S corps.

You will maintain compliance by:

  • Holding regular shareholder or member meetings and director meetings;
  • Keeping corporate minutes of the meetings;
  • Maintaining financial records of all business income;
  • Filing tax forms to pay federal and state taxes;
  • Paying reasonable minimum salaries to shareholders or members (W-2).

Losing your S corp status could have serious liability and tax effects. You should have a corporate attorney prepare a compliance plan to make sure your corporation satisfies all its regulatory obligations.

Comparison: S Corp vs. Other Business Entities

Before forming an S corporation, you must understand how it can benefit owners of small businesses in New York. The table compares different legal entity types so you can make informed decisions about your company's structure.

AspectS CorporationC CorporationSole ProprietorshipPartnershipLimited Liability Company (LLC)
Limited LiabilityYesYesYesYesYes
TaxationPass-throughDouble taxationPass-throughPass-throughFlexibility to choose taxation
Ownership StructureShareholdersShareholdersIndividualPartnersMembers
Number of OwnersUp to 100UnlimitedIndividual owner2 or more ownersUnlimited
FormalitiesModerateMore formalMinimalModerateModerate
Capital RaisingLimitedEasier access to capitalPersonal funds onlyPersonal funds and loansFlexible
Management StructureDirectors and OfficersDirectors and OfficersIndividualPartnersFlexibility to choose a structure
Compliance RequirementsOngoing corporate formalitiesOngoing corporate formalitiesMinimalModerateModerate
Business ContinuityContinues upon the owner's deathContinues upon the owner's deathEnds with ownerContinues upon partner's departureContinuity depends on provisions

S corporations provide an attractive combination of pass-through taxation and limited liability protection. Assess your needs and consult a professional about whether an S corp will meet your needs. You can contact a lawyer or find other resources that can guide you in forming an S corp for your venture.

Take Your Business to the Next Level with Lawyer For Business: Request a Legal Consultation Now!

An S corp can solve problems faced by owners of small businesses. These entities can reduce your corporate and self-employment tax burdens while limiting your liability.

Lawyer For Business provides knowledge and experience as you navigate the process of forming a New York S corp. With legal assistance, you will form your corporation correctly, maintain New York state and federal compliance, and maximize its benefits.

Contact us for personalized legal guidance as you explore how an S corp can save you money and address the challenges your company faces.

Ready to Incorporate as an S Corp in NY? Consult Our Lawyer Today!

Elevate your business with S Corp status. Contact us for tailored legal strategies.

Schedule Consultation

Buffalo Business Lawyer Serving New York State
Andrea A. Willis, Esq. is an award-winning attorney that delivers top-notch service to her clients. She has a diverse background representing business clients from many sectors and sizes.

Back to Blog

Table of Contents


Can I convert my existing business entity into an S Corp in New York?

Yes. You can easily convert a C corporation or limited liability company to an S corp by changing its tax election with the IRS. Converting other entity types, such as sole proprietorships, will require you to form a new corporation by filing articles of incorporation and paying a filing fee.

How can an S Corp help small business owners save on Taxes?

Tax benefits of an S corp come in many forms, including:

  • Pass-through treatment of business income;
  • Possible reduction in self-employment taxes and Medicare taxes for a reasonable salary.

You should consult a tax professional to review all the possible tax savings.

Can I have multiple shareholders in an S Corp in New York?

Yes, a New York S corp can have any number of shareholders, from an individual shareholder up to 100 shareholders, including:

  • People
  • Trusts
  • Estates
  • 501(c)(3) charities

In general, Corporations, LLCs, and partnerships cannot hold shares in an S corp.  The exception is that a single-member LLC may own shares in an S corp.

Are there any specific industries or professions that cannot form an S Corp in New York?

Yes, some businesses, like investment companies, insurance companies, and financial institutions, cannot operate as S corps. This happens because of the accounting method they use to handle bad debts.

Other businesses can form an S corp but must limit their management structure. For example, medical practices cannot have non-doctor shareholders.